Can a company’s internal auditors conduct an ASI certification audit?
Internal auditors can play an important role in preparing for the audit, but ASI certification audits must be carried out by an independent third-party audit team from an ASI Accredited Auditing Firm.
19 November 2026
When preparing for ASI Certification, members sometimes ask whether their internal auditors can complete ASI training and conduct the certification audit. Internal auditors can play an important role in preparing for the audit, but ASI certification audits must be carried out by an independent third-party audit team from an ASI Accredited Auditing Firm.

Why independent audits matter for ASI Certification
When independent auditors evaluate evidence against the applicable ASI Standard and its criteria, the outcome gives customers, suppliers and other stakeholders confidence that the conformance with ASI requirements has been assessed by an impartial team outside of the company. Stakeholders can then use that assessment to inform sourcing decisions and understand how a company manages sustainability issues within its certification scope.
ASI’s Assurance Manual sets common requirements for how accredited firms plan, conduct and report audits. This supports a consistent auditing approach across the companies being audited all along the aluminium value chain, from bauxite mining to downstream manufacturing.
How internal auditors can help
Internal auditors can use ASI’s online learning resources on educationAL to build their understanding of the Standards and the assurance process. They can review how their company’s systems and practices address the applicable ASI Standard, identify gaps and help prepare the ASI Self-Assessment.
An internal auditor’s relationship with the company creates a conflict of interest if they are asked to conduct its certification audit. For example, an auditor who helped prepare the ASI Self-Assessment should not be tasked with evaluating the same evidence they helped compile. An independent audit team assesses that evidence without bias or self-interest in the company and its operations.
Summary table: Internal vs independent auditors in ASI Certification
| Aspect | Internal auditors | Independent third-party auditors |
|---|---|---|
| Role | Review the member’s systems and practices, identify gaps and help prepare the ASI Self-Assessment. | Evaluate evidence against the applicable ASI Standard within the company’s certification scope. |
| Training and accreditation | Can use ASI’s educational resources to build their understanding of the Standards and the assurance process. Cannot be ASI accredited. | Must apply for individual accreditation through an ASI Accredited Auditing Firm and meet ASI’s competence and accreditation requirements. |
| Independence and eligibility | Can help prepare their company for certification. Their relationship with the company prevents them from conducting the certification audit. | Must be independent of the company they audit and conduct the certification audit as part of a team from an ASI Accredited Auditing Firm. |
| How they work | Tailor internal reviews to the member’s operations and priorities. | Follow the ASI Assurance Manual, which sets common audit requirements across firms and value chain segments. |
| How their findings are used | Can help the member address gaps and improve its systems before and after the audit. | Inform the certification decision. |
Key takeaways
- Internal auditors help prepare your company for certification. They can identify gaps and support the ASI Self-Assessment.
- ASI training alone does not confer accreditation. To become accredited, auditors must apply through an ASI Accredited Auditing Firm and meet ASI’s competence and accreditation requirements.
- Certification audits require independence. Engage an independent ASI Accredited Auditing Firm to carry out your certification audit.
Your next steps
- Use educationAL to build your internal team’s understanding of the ASI Standards and the assurance process.
- Ask your internal auditors to review your systems against the applicable ASI Standard and help prepare your ASI Self-Assessment.
- Use the directory of ASI Accredited Auditing Firms to find an eligible, independent firm for your certification audit.
If you have questions about training or auditor eligibility, contact Emily Jones, Program Administrator.
SHARE THIS ARTICLE